Another Nobel for neutrinos: An INO scientist reflects

As one of the physicists behind India’s pursuit for a neutrino detector under its own soil, Indumathi D. has no regrets, but is very aware of what we have lost.
By | Published on Oct 16, 2026

One of the first lectures Indumathi D. delivered to her new colleagues at Bengaluru’s Indian Institute of Astrophysics (IIA) was about a recent paper that showed how it was possible to use the high energy neutrinos detected by the IceCube detector in the South Pole to observe the universe, just as we know telescopes to. “I found it interesting but never imagined it could win a Nobel!” laughed the particle physicist who recently retired from Chennai’s Institute of Mathematical Sciences (IMSc). 

I caught up with her the day after the 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics was awarded to Francis Halzen “for decisive contributions to the IceCube Neutrino Observatory and the discovery of high-energy neutrinos of astrophysical origin”. The glint of excitement in Indu’s eyes when she talks about IceCube stems not only from her identity as a particle physicist specialising in neutrinos, but also from her involvement with one of India’s most ambitious science projects. She was part of the original team of Indian physicists who conceived of India’s own underground neutrino detector, the India-based Neutrino Observatory (INO), almost three decades back. For a number of reasons, political rather than scientific or logistic, INO never materialised. Today, the project stands all but shelved, and most of the scientists behind it have crossed retirement age.

I asked Indu to share her feelings about IceCube, the latest Nobel Prize, and the INO journey. I expected her to get wistful but instead found her resilient and even, to my surprise, optimistic. Excerpts from our interview.

Nandita (N): In many ways, IceCube seems to be the golden standard for neutrino observatories. Does that mean that any other detector, whether the Super-Kamiokande or the INO can only do some of the things that IceCube can, and not as well?

Indu (I): That’s not true. With larger detectors, you can look at very very high energy neutrinos, where the secondary particles emitted are kicked in the forward direction. So you can “point back” to the source, and this pointing back is what allows you to do astrophysics. 

An artist’s composition of the Milky Way seen through a neutrino lens (blue). Credit: IceCube Collaboration/U.S. National Science Foundation

But for this, you have to reach energies at which you can forget about ordinary atmospheric neutrinos which are produced when cosmic rays interact with Earth’s atmosphere. As you go beyond 100 GeV, beyond 1 TeV, 10 TeV, 100 TeV (these are units of energy that tell you how much energy neutrinos carry), you increasingly start to see neutrinos which have come from outside our atmosphere. IceCube opened the door to multi-messenger astronomy, meaning that just as you can observe an object out in space with electromagnetic radiation—visible, infrared, ultraviolet, or whatever—you can now observe it using neutrinos. It’s true that no other detector can do this. 

When it comes to neutrino oscillations, there is a golden window: that 5 to 10 GeV where the matter effects are large, and we can distinguish the mass hierarchy. Icecube can detect these low energy neutrinos as well, thanks to a sub-array inside it called Deep Core, but the quality of reconstruction is not as good, and these neutrinos don’t point back. 

The INO detector, on the other hand, was optimised to distinguish neutrino and anti-neutrino events to study the neutrino mass ordering, something which IceCube cannot do because it does not have the magnetic field discrimination that INO had. IceCube is an amazing experiment with a broad canvas, while INO would have been a focussed experiment.

IceCube is a large collaboration and we could have been a part of it, but to build something here, to put the nuts and bolts, to have every component actually built in India… that was much bigger.

N: When this Nobel was announced for IceCube’s discoveries, how did you feel? 

I: Actually, when I first heard the news I felt like such an idiot [laughs]. Just in March or April, when the pointing back data came, I gave a talk at IIA. I spoke about how active galactic nuclei or blazars emit these jets, or some energetic outflows of protons. Usually there is a huge intergalactic magnetic field across the universe, which we don’t really know very well. The protons keep turning in the magnetic field, so that when it hits the Earth and you detect it, it no longer points back to where it was produced. But you see, neutrinos do not bend in the magnetic field. So it makes sense to point it back. 

I found this paper interesting but never imagined it could win a Nobel! Clearly, I’m not a judge of good physics! [smiles]

An artistic rendering of the IceCube Lab at the South Pole. Credit: IceCube/NSF

N: I couldn’t disagree more, Indu! I do wonder though: was there not an inkling of bitterness or sadness you felt about what Indian neutrino physics was missing out on? 

I: Not at all. See, the thing is, even if I wasn’t involved with INO, it’s special to have a Nobel Prize in your area, right? Everyone asks us, would you have won a Nobel. I don’t know… I don’t think we would have got a Nobel Prize, [but I do think] things would be different for India. We would have started a culture of doing experimental activity. 

N: Talks about INO started early in 2000. In a parallel universe, let’s say it all went to plan and the detector was launched according to plan in 2012. What would the particle physics ecosystem in India look like today?

I: I don’t need to imagine a parallel universe to answer this. I can actually tell you from my experiences. You see, it was a case of “the operation was successful, but the patient died”. We had more than 50 graduate students. We had interactions with I think 60-70 companies and factories who manufactured things. There’s something you should remember: IceCube is a large collaboration and we could have been a part of it. But to build something here… to put the nuts and bolts, to have every component actually built in India… to make the prototype in the lab, to move to the industry… that was much bigger.

I don’t think we would have got a Nobel Prize, [but I do think] things would be different for India. We would have started a culture of doing experimental activity. 

We are talking about 50,000 tonnes of iron, 20,000 RPCs (Resistive Plate Chambers). The Sriperumbudur factory of Saint Gobain actually made an R&D department for us! Our group went there and told them how to set it up, what to do, and helped them set up the prototypes. They manufactured 400 RPCs for us.

Students involved in testing and calibrating of the INO in Madurai. Photo sourced from Inmathi platform.

The INO made a big difference. Firstly, with students. So many students worked on the prototype through COVID.  Thousands of local students have worked on the project. We tried to start particle physics in Madurai Kamaraj University. In fact, Murthy (M.V.N. Murthy) and Rajaji (G. Rajasekaran) actually taught several semesters of the course there. Our own graduate students had this interaction with cutting-edge technology transfer to industry. They were so eager and keen and enthusiastic. See, they are also tired of just manufacturing some boring stuff for the market. They also want to do R&D. That I think is incredible. The amount of geology I learned, the amount of environmental science I learned, the number of people I interacted with and got to know their concerns. See, this would not have happened if I had just been doing some normal physics inside IMSc. I think nobody can take that away from us.

Thousands of local students have worked on the project. They were so eager and keen and enthusiastic. See, they are also tired of just manufacturing some boring stuff for the market. They also want to do R&D.

What used to pain me—and it took me a while to get over it—was how many people told lies about INO. It’s not just people who have their own agenda, but people within the physics community who have not understood the project. With IceCube, people are now again talking about INO. I read someone say “Oh, they should not have put it in the forest in the first place”, but this project was not in the forest, right? You expect scientists to be more intelligent and better read than that, right? To be very very frank, nobody supported INO from the community. For me that was the most painful part. Besides this my experience with INO is always positive. The group that we built… adversity made us very close. 

N: Could we ever see a revival for INO?

I: I joined INO when I was 36 years old and at the time a senior physicist asked me, “What are you as a theorist doing in an experimental project, you won’t get a promotion. Why don’t you simply sit and write papers?” I am 63 now and I have never regretted this. Maybe I wrote 10 fewer papers, but who cares? Writing papers is not the aim of my life. Today, we are all retired. And the generation of physicists who spent their lives building things, that generation is gone. Most people are now involved with data analysis rather than building things. 

There was a golden window, and we actually have lost that. It will be very difficult now—even if you have the right political and social support—to find the people who can actually build something from scratch. It’s not that it cannot be done, but we will be much further behind. 

I still feel that it is worth trying. I think we should not give up so easily. I don’t mean to sound egotistical but I do feel that if we don’t do it, nobody will do it. That is the honest truth. Because we are not doing this for ourselves. It was always for the next generation. That feeling should be there among people.

[Featured image credit: Indumathi D., with the background from INO’s 2006 project report]

About the author(s)